Scrappy’s Story – Part 2: Recovery

In Part I of Scrappy’s story, I explained that he came to my house after he was returned by his first adopters. The family did not feel they could keep him because he barked and growled at outsiders. He didn’t seem safe. After he came back to us, some of the volunteers at Homeward Bound were uncomfortable with him, as well. This was partly due to his inordinately large eyes and his habit of staring. Worse, he would unexpectedly lunge at strangers and even some other dogs. I take some of Homeward Bound’s dogs with challenging behaviors to work with them. I took Scrappy so he wouldn’t get himself in trouble.

Scrapper stayed in my kennels because he was considered to be not dog-friendly. At the time, I had two dogs in the house. I usually spend the first day or two observing a new dog to see if I can witness the behaviors others have reported. Sometimes a different environment has a positive effect on a dog but not in Scrap’s case. Vehicles passing by induced a frantic run at the fence accompanied by sustained, loud, and almost hysterical barking.


I once left a garbage bin in the yard that stopped Scrappy in his tracks. He alternately charged and retreated from this menace — complete with a soundtrack of barking and growling intended to ward off this threat. I can imagine that Scrappy was perplexed by this … thing that inexplicably stood its ground in the face of Scrap’s fury.

I started taking Scrappy over to Homeward Bound every day for our walks. These trips confirmed the lunging I had heard about. He didn’t go after every new person or every dog but it happened often enough to verify that Scrappy was not a safe in his current state. I don’t know what he would have done had he actually reached anyone – but the lunging itself could not be tolerated. This was a serious issue that had to be addressed.


I felt completely safe myself with Scrappy. But that’s not enough. If we made him available for adoption, I felt responsible for his actions and the safety of everyone involved. That’s sobering. Based on our own interaction it was hard to imagine Scrappy being a danger to anyone. We’d hang out in the yard and he seemed a pretty normal dog except for an undercurrent of tension if you observed closely. He’d let me touch him, but he wasn’t all that affectionate.

I liked him, but wasn’t particularly drawn to him – until one day. I was replacing a bad sprinkler head. Scrappy came over and lay down, politely, a couple feet away and watched. I looked at him and he looked at me. I went back to the sprinkler and he resumed watching what I was doing. I looked at him again and he returned my gaze. We repeated this exchange a couple more times and then I stopped and turned to Scrappy, swallowing hard to dislodge the lump in my throat. I promised him I would never let anything bad happen to him. So that was that. I was committed.


Fortunately, Scrappy is food-motivated. This makes him easy to work with. First, I wanted to establish Scrappy’s threshold; the imaginary line where his anxiety took over and turned him into a little terror. While this reaction was not always consistent, I gradually worked at reducing this threshold by rewarding calm behavior with treats and affection. I challenged Scrappy a little at a time until he became more accustomed to calmly approaching people and dogs.

In a nutshell, we gradually worked at reducing the threshold by rewarding calm behavior with treats and affection. We challenged Scrappy a little at a time so that he could approach people and dogs with less anxiety. This wasn’t always easy to put into practice because he didn’t lunge at everyone and didn’t even always go after the same person. Except Maria, one of our gardeners. Maria was his mortal enemy.

Scrap’s progress was steady and eventually his lunging became infrequent. But he had some setbacks to. One time someone he knew and liked was installing bricks on the path in the garden. For some mystifying reason Scrappy took exception to her activity. She got the ugly face along with some unpleasant vocalizations.

Scrappy posing

There were a few times I thought that Scrappy was almost ready to be adopted. But then he would relapse and we would continue with his rehabilitation. At one point I became convinced he was ready. It had been weeks since an incident and he was approaching strangers with more confidence than ever. Naturally, I watched him carefully during each interaction so I could take appropriate action if necessary. Visitors on our property were now a good thing — most of the time. I was sure it was Scrappy’s time. He had even made peace with his enemy, Maria.

Scrappy, Maria, and Yule

But it was not to be. Not long after I was walking Scrap next to a yard where a family was meeting one of our dogs. A little girl about six years old was at the end of the yard just on the other side of the fence. From my human point of view there was nothing this girl did to set Scrappy off. But Scrappy must have perceived some kind of threat because he lunged at her. She was never in danger being on the other side of the fence. But my heart sank because I knew what this meant: I could never make Scrappy available for adoption. Despite the incredible progress he had made, I could not take the chance.

So that meant Scrappy was staying with me, and it wouldn’t be right to keep him in my kennels.  But I still had BoBo and Shaggy in the house, and Scrap had not been tested with any dogs since he came back to us. I was nervous about making the necessary introductions because this one was a bit more complicated than most. So I secured the help of Kathryn Baines of Golden Rule Training to make sure it went smoothly. The first meeting went okay but was not without issues. A couple days later we put them together again and it went … fabulously. You can see the three of them below watching the goats next door.

BoBo, Scrappy, and Shaggy

That was just about a year ago. I can’t imagine life without Scrappy now.

But this is not the end of Scrappy’s Story. Stay tuned for Part 3.


  1. […] Story. In Part 1: Descent I explained what brought Scrappy to my house for work on some issues. Part 2: Recovery described how we helped Scrappy interact better with people and other dogs. Although he became a […]


  2. Thank you for sharing this story. Rescue is always a hard and rocky road, and so often it’s a thankless one — so a big thank you from our family!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Aw, i’m glad to do it.


  3. Jana

    Scrappy has come so far. He is in such good hands with Rob. Scrappy does have beautiful eyes.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you, Jana. I went back and checked to make sure I hadn’t posted a photo of Max instead.


  4. Kathryn

    Love Scrappy – he is a special boy


  5. Cindy Towne

    I know there is a happy ending but, I want to see how it all came about.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I may not have achieved everything I wanted for him but sometimes “good enough” is till pretty darn good.


  6. sargentmt

    Ahh Scrappy! I was stressed more than once when Scrappy came through the garden. So glad we are friends now. I’m so glad Yule has found a friend. He has turned out to be quite a special dog for all of HB.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m glad he has so many friends.


  7. derrycats

    Scrappy is very fortunate that you took him in! Great job with him.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you.


  8. That is still like reading Ray’s diary. We taught him to make eye contact so we knew we had his attention when training him. He did it so well that his “Rotti eyes” stare made some people uncomfortable. He hasn’t challenged a garbage can yet, but he has stalked a plastic bag. As for other people and dogs? All were to be feared and driven away but, after just over two years, he now sees them as potential reasons for treats and greets quite happily. If he had not been food motivated, things could have been much more complicated.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Perhaps they are distant cousins. Kindred spirits at least.

      Liked by 1 person

  9. Mary Tonningsen

    It’s like a Doggie Soap Opera! I’m hooked on Scrappy’s story 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. One more episode to go.

      Liked by 1 person

  10. Scrappy has come so far. He’d be a lucky dog to stay with you forever. Looking forward to Part III.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you, Ogee-Wan.

      Liked by 1 person

  11. Wonderful story — can hardly wait to read the next installment

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you, Eric.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.